Tesi etd-09082023-112044 |
Link copiato negli appunti
Tipo di tesi
Tesi di laurea magistrale LM6
Autore
MERELLA, EDOARDO
URN
etd-09082023-112044
Titolo
Mathematical Approach for Ring Size Prediction in Degenerative Mitral Valve Repair
Dipartimento
RICERCA TRASLAZIONALE E DELLE NUOVE TECNOLOGIE IN MEDICINA E CHIRURGIA
Corso di studi
MEDICINA E CHIRURGIA
Relatori
.
relatore Prof. Colli, Andrea
correlatore Dott. Fiocco, Alessandro
correlatore Dott. Fiocco, Alessandro
Parole chiave
- annuloplasty
- mitral valve
- ring size prediction
Data inizio appello
26/09/2023
Consultabilità
Completa
Riassunto (Inglese)
Riassunto (Italiano)
Background - The implantation of a prosthetic ring during Mitral Valve Repair (MVRe) is a pillar in valvular surgery. The sizing is usually assessed during the surgery, based on well established, eye-ball techniques.
Preoperative prediction of the correct ring-size, through a mathematical approach, could be a useful tool to help the surgeon’s choice.
Objective - The aim of the study is to evaluate a new formula to perform a preoperative prediction of the prosthetic ring/band size to be implanted in surgical MVRe. We therefore propose a mathematical approach based on transthoracic echocardiography measurements developed to achieve a coaptation length (CL) of 8 millimeters in order to obtain an optimal repair.
Methods - Patients affected by Degenerative Mitral Valve Regurgitation (DMR), who underwent surgical MVRe from July 2021 to July 2023, were retrospectively evaluated. Pre-operative Coaptation Length (CL0) and antero-posterior (AP) diameter have been measured in PLAX view during telesystole, while Anterior Mitral Leaflet (AML) length, Posterior Mitral Leaflet length (PML) in mid-diastole. All measurements were performed three times by one operator (EM) and then blindly validated by an expert echocardiographer (GSF). Mean values were calculated and then plotted into the ideated formula. A CL of 8 mm was selected, based on literature showing a long-lasting effective MVRe necessitates of a post-operative CL between 5 and 10 mm. The following formula was developed: .
The prosthetic ring/band corresponding to the pAP was selected in blind respect to the ring/band that was actually implanted.
Using the pAP, the surgeon can then, using the charts provided by each manufacturer, deduct and confirm the most appropriate ring size for the annuloplasty.
A concordance study was developed using the two tailed t-test for paired samples and the Pearson correlation coefficient test (PCC).
To compare categorical and continuous variables, which could have influenced the concordance, we usedChi-squared test and two-tailed t-test for unpaired samples, respectively.
Results - Fifty-four patients were included in the study; 6 implanted a SimuPlus Band (SPB), 17 CG Future Band (CGFB) and 31 Simulus Ring (SR) (Medtronic, Minneapolis, MN USA). 32 (57,1%) patients were males and 24 (42,9%) females, with a mean age of 64 ±13.
Mean Left Ventricular Ejection Fraction (LVEF) was 61% ±6.
Their data were collected retrospectively and analyzed. Pearson test showed a good correlation between the predicted and surgically measured and implanted ring sizes (PCC r: 0,589; p <0,001). No correlation was found between categorical and continuous variables and the concordance of the prediction, except for the ring type. In details, SR and CGFB demonstrated different correlations (r=0,745, P<0,001; r=0,659; p=0,004; respectively). SPB showed no correlation.
Discussion and Conclusion - The proposed method showed good results in terms of ring size prediction, using a non-invasive, wide available and cost-effective method. In details, its efficiency was superior in case of semi-rigid, complete ring; acceptable in case of semirigid, incomplete band; and unsuccessful in case of a soft, incomplete band.
The ring-size prediction has been already described by other studies. Most of them reported the use of TC scan, 3D-printed models, invasive examinations, software processing or complex multi-parametric formulas. All the previously reported methods appear to be expensive and require a lot of funds, a higher level of complexity and have lower reproducibility. The proposed mathematical formula represents an easier, repeatable, cost-effective and readily available method for ring size prediction, and could be helpful in the surgeon’s choice.
Further studies are needed to investigate the effectiveness in a larger population and the potential utilization in transcatheter annuloplasty solutions.
Preoperative prediction of the correct ring-size, through a mathematical approach, could be a useful tool to help the surgeon’s choice.
Objective - The aim of the study is to evaluate a new formula to perform a preoperative prediction of the prosthetic ring/band size to be implanted in surgical MVRe. We therefore propose a mathematical approach based on transthoracic echocardiography measurements developed to achieve a coaptation length (CL) of 8 millimeters in order to obtain an optimal repair.
Methods - Patients affected by Degenerative Mitral Valve Regurgitation (DMR), who underwent surgical MVRe from July 2021 to July 2023, were retrospectively evaluated. Pre-operative Coaptation Length (CL0) and antero-posterior (AP) diameter have been measured in PLAX view during telesystole, while Anterior Mitral Leaflet (AML) length, Posterior Mitral Leaflet length (PML) in mid-diastole. All measurements were performed three times by one operator (EM) and then blindly validated by an expert echocardiographer (GSF). Mean values were calculated and then plotted into the ideated formula. A CL of 8 mm was selected, based on literature showing a long-lasting effective MVRe necessitates of a post-operative CL between 5 and 10 mm. The following formula was developed: .
The prosthetic ring/band corresponding to the pAP was selected in blind respect to the ring/band that was actually implanted.
Using the pAP, the surgeon can then, using the charts provided by each manufacturer, deduct and confirm the most appropriate ring size for the annuloplasty.
A concordance study was developed using the two tailed t-test for paired samples and the Pearson correlation coefficient test (PCC).
To compare categorical and continuous variables, which could have influenced the concordance, we usedChi-squared test and two-tailed t-test for unpaired samples, respectively.
Results - Fifty-four patients were included in the study; 6 implanted a SimuPlus Band (SPB), 17 CG Future Band (CGFB) and 31 Simulus Ring (SR) (Medtronic, Minneapolis, MN USA). 32 (57,1%) patients were males and 24 (42,9%) females, with a mean age of 64 ±13.
Mean Left Ventricular Ejection Fraction (LVEF) was 61% ±6.
Their data were collected retrospectively and analyzed. Pearson test showed a good correlation between the predicted and surgically measured and implanted ring sizes (PCC r: 0,589; p <0,001). No correlation was found between categorical and continuous variables and the concordance of the prediction, except for the ring type. In details, SR and CGFB demonstrated different correlations (r=0,745, P<0,001; r=0,659; p=0,004; respectively). SPB showed no correlation.
Discussion and Conclusion - The proposed method showed good results in terms of ring size prediction, using a non-invasive, wide available and cost-effective method. In details, its efficiency was superior in case of semi-rigid, complete ring; acceptable in case of semirigid, incomplete band; and unsuccessful in case of a soft, incomplete band.
The ring-size prediction has been already described by other studies. Most of them reported the use of TC scan, 3D-printed models, invasive examinations, software processing or complex multi-parametric formulas. All the previously reported methods appear to be expensive and require a lot of funds, a higher level of complexity and have lower reproducibility. The proposed mathematical formula represents an easier, repeatable, cost-effective and readily available method for ring size prediction, and could be helpful in the surgeon’s choice.
Further studies are needed to investigate the effectiveness in a larger population and the potential utilization in transcatheter annuloplasty solutions.
File
| Nome file | Dimensione |
|---|---|
| TesiEdoa...rella.pdf | 3.88 Mb |
Contatta l’autore |
|